This is a finalist in the challenge Whodunit?!

Never Trust A Social Butterfly

A   A   Print

Never Trust A Social Butterfly

Their wings drip of venom.



It's clear that whoever pulled the prank has an in-depth knowledge of the social crowd, and wanted to get them all. Although the others might toy with the idea, it's Scarlet who would have the clearest motive.

Scarlet has already proven herself to be a liar and manipulative, telling sob stories to get closer to her next target. She's the type who would care about the social scene, and care deeply. Popularity is a big thing for her, and what better way to make her more popular than making everyone else look worse?

Also, Scarlet is probably the catty type, and would like to get back at a lot of her gossipy friends. However, if it was pinned on her, she'd get the blame and be shunned, so she would have to keep it a secret.

Scarlet isn't dumb, but she would probably have needed help from a random geek, AV or otherwise. It would be a simple matter for her; all she'd have to do would be to bat her eyelashes and turn on the charm. Mentioning a person on the list that the geek didn't like, and the deal would be sealed.

To conclude, Scarlet is the one with the biggest motive to pull off the prank, as well as the most manipulative one, which would be a factor in pulling it off.

A   A   Print
Views: 613
()
Likes
4

Comments (1-4 of 4)

Log in to post a comment
osakaxxlaka
Nov 19, 2008 04:06PM
Actually, my theory came too late to submit, so, I'll out it here.

Jonah did it.

I mean, he's the stereotypical stupid jock, so how would he know about the church performer Martin Luther? (Look at episode #6)
shilom
Nov 17, 2008 01:57PM
Very convincing! Of the 5, she's my pick too.
alemuji
Nov 17, 2008 12:27PM
this one is actually decent
thehoodedmenace
Nov 17, 2008 01:55PM
Thanks? xD
ness
Nov 17, 2008 12:22PM
Congrats on being a finalist. I really like your idea about Scarlet. I think that she is somehow involved too. But perhaps she's smarter than we think. What if she did use a geek to pull off a Martin Luther thing!
thehoodedmenace
Nov 17, 2008 01:56PM
She could be smarter than she looks, which I hope. Exploiting geeks is smart. But mean D:
Log in to post a comment

Details

Posted By: thehoodedmenace
Published: Nov 15, 2008
Honors: Producer Choice: Never Trust A Social Butterfly Jan 23, 2009 Finalist Submission: Never Trust A Social Butterfly Nov 17, 2008
Episodes:

Challenge

Tell us who you think pulled the prank, and how and why they did it.

Summary

Their wings drip of venom.

Tags

butterfly, scarlet, social, lies

More from thehoodedmenace

on November 15 2008 | Views: 177 | Length: 102 words  
on October 20 2008 | Views: 439 | Length: 38S  
on November 23 2008 | Views: 603 | Length: 54S  
on November 16 2008 | Views: 170 | Length: 163 words  
on October 28 2008 | Views: 348 | Length: 50S  
see all »